Gumby's Pizza How do you like your pizza? Gumby’s offers one of the best menus for pizza restaurants in Tallahassee. Located at 623 W. Tennessee Street, we’ve got it any way you like it - thick crust or thin; loaded with meat, or our crowd-pleasing Spicy Chef’s Special Veggie. Or, try our renowned Pokey Stix, Buffalo wings, or one of our salads – Greek, Spinach, or Buffalo Chicken. We have a large and varied assortment of toppings, so hop online and tell us how you like it, and your delivery will be hot and fresh! If you would rather have it to-go, order online or call, and we’ll have it ready for you to pickup. Order Online Payment Options